Most people especially Christian leaders are trained to believe that the way that they were taught to believe is right and everything else is heresy. I like to try to understand where people are coming from and see how their beliefs compares to what the Bible teaches. While there are some Doctrines that are non-negotiable, most of our disputes do not fall into that category. What I try to do is to listen to where others are coming from and the scriptural basis for their views. Then I list the view as either probable (what I believe), plausible (basically scripurally equal to what I believe), possible (could be, but not something that I'm likely to believe), or forgery (fake or false teaching).
Since it is getting close to Christmas, I will try to show how I use this method with four different versions about where Jesus was born. I will not post the entire Christmas story here, but it is found in The Gospel of Luke chapter 2. Here are the four versions of this story that I have heard proclaimed and this is how I go about ranking them.
Story #1. Jesus was born in a Delivery Stable because there was no more rooms in the local motel.
Story #2. Jesus was born in a part of the family's house that was reserve for animals.
Story #3. Jesus was born in a cave right outside the city.
Story #4. The town where Jesus was a different Bethlehem than we are led to believe.
First, we look at Story #1. This comes almost directly from a lot of Bible translations and is what has been taught throughout the ages. This one needs to be either probable or plausible.
When we look at Story #2 we see this. This story focuses on the word that is usually translated "Inn". When we consult our Strong's or Interlinear Bibles, we see that the Greek word has this meaning - guestchamber, inn. This word is used a couple of more times in Scriptures (Mark 14:14 and Luke 22:11) and each of those times it is translated guest room. Also, the Jewish people at this time are one big family that are descendants of Jacob (aka Israel). Hospitality is a big thing among them and sharing their space with others. Also, since there are no refrigeration or cars at this time, most houses would have a room much like our garages, but live animals would be kept there - for food or traveling. With all this study, I would put this in either the probable or plausible category.
The background on Story #3 is about where the stable would be located. They suggest that a cave would be a more likely place to house animals and caves are more likely to be found right outside the city's buildings. I do not know the geography there and so I would rate this as a possibility, I can't say that this wouldn't be the case, but the fact that the Shepherds were sent into the city by the Angels suggest to me that this would not be the more likely scenario.
Now we come to story #4 and I rate this one as a forgery. The Bethlehem that Joseph and Mary was sent to was the city (the birthplace) of King David and that city is the one in Judah close to Jerusalem.
I hope that this helps. One of the things that has caused me to start looking that things this way goes back to the way the Pharisees and other Jews rejected Jesus. They were so caught up into their own interpretations of scripture, that they missed God telling them the correct way to interpret those passages.